UPDATE:Student
protests live coverage
As parliament votes on
higher tuition fees thousands of students are
marching in London and Edinburgh. Follow the
latest here. Send us your news:
@peterwalker99
peter.walker@guardian.co.uk
Student protests live coverage and an
education by Police Thugs who are unable to
target the real trouble makers, strangers, not
students. Charging with horses, is the action of
thugs.
As parliament votes on
higher tuition fees thousands of students are
marching in London and Edinburgh. Follow the
latest here. Send us your news:
@peterwalker99
peter.walker@guardian.co.uk
Student protestors gather for a march on
parliament. Photograph: Peter Macdiarmid/Getty
Images
5.06pm:
The Guardian's
Jonathan Haynes calls me from Whitehall. He
says that while the "kettle" on
Parliament Square is being officers where he is
just near the Cenotaph won't let
anyone out, even the media. He's shown his press
card to two police but remains penned in. There
are riot police and mounted officers and they are,
he says, using "very heavy handed"
tactics striding into a passive crowd to
shove people backwards.
4.31pm:
Our very own Caroline
Davies emails me with this:
Shiv Malik, 29, a journalist, gave the
Guardian this account from a cab on his way
to University College Hospital for treatment
to a head wound caused by a police baton. He
was in Parliament Square at the junction with
Victoria Street caught between the police
line and the students, who were moving the
fence up in an attempt to break through.
"The crowd surged in an attempt to
break through the police line, and I was
caught on the same side as the police but
facing towards them with the fence behind me.
The fence came right up to the police line.
The police started to push back then they
started using their batons on protesters. I
was caught then and pushed up towards the
front. I ducked, my glasses were knocked off
my face so I was trying to hold them. Then,
basically, a baton strike came to the side of
my face and then onto the top of my head.
Directly onto the crown of my head. I felt a
big whacking thud and I heard it
reverberating inside my head.
"I wasn't sure whether I was bleeding or
not. I moved off to the side and asked a
police officer if I was bleeding. But he just
said 'Keep moving, keep moving". Then I
put my hand to the top of my head and looked
at my palm and I could see there was blood
everywhere. I then asked another police
officer, who was wearing a police medic badge,
if he could help me. And he told me to move
away as well and told me to go to another
exit. By this point blood was streaming down
the back of my head and back of my neck and
matting my hair. I was wearing a roll neck
jumper and it was seeping into the back of my
jumper. I managed to come off to one side and
make my way out where two protesting student
helped me. They were cleaning the top of my
head with water and some tissues. Someone in
the crowd gave me a whole pack of Kleenex.
Then two female protestors escorted me out. I
had to walk all the way up to Leicester
Square where I managed to catch a cab.
I don't know the extent of my injury. I've
been told it's about an inch long gash right
at the top of my crown. It stopped bleeding
now, but it was bleeding badly for about ten
minutes."
what do they
think they are doing to peaceful protest?A
student medical steward he's a trained St
John's Ambulance member has phoned in to
say he's treated at least 10 head injuries from
marchers being hit with police batons, around two
thirds of which were serious enough to need
hospital treatment.
Finally, Scotland Yard say two officers have
been injured, one knocked unconscious who's
suffered head injuries, and one with leg injuries
after being knocked from his horse.
4.18pm: BBC
News showing slightly ominous footage of police
horses lining up in the dusk. More charges coming,
I expect.
3.29pm: It's probably high time
we had a recap:
As MPs debate higher tuition fees
in the Commons tens of thousands of students and
others have marched through central
London towards Parliament Square.
The vast bulk of the protest has
been peaceful and good-natured, those on
the ground say.
However, there have been some
isolated skirmishes, mainly protesters
using barriers to try and force back police lines.
Some placards and flares have been thrown.
Scotland Yard says that so far
there has been just one arrest (for
drunk and disorderly) and no reported injuries,
though both could change.
Police have seemingly not been
able to contain marchers as they had
hoped. A large nunber have spilled onto the green
of Parliament Square, painting a giant "No"
in red paint.
Some officers have donned riot
gear and police horses are in place.
There has been a smaller march in
Newcastle and later today students in
Edinburgh will hold a rally at the Scottish
parliament.
2.52pm Guardian's Jonathan
Haynes, who's currently getting to know his
fellow marchers much better inside Parliament
Square:Hello - trapped in crush where police hold
protest back outside parliament sure you
have better view on TV. Crowd have homemade
shields. One young protester picked up brick
immediately told by all around to put it
down. Things have been thrown at police though
crowd increasing frustrated at having
nowhere to go. Current discussion is whether
protest in now kettled, no on seems to know.
12.32pm Protesters listening to
speeches near Russell Square, marshalled by
police. Numbers are swelling rapidly,
predominantly university students but younger and
older faces too. Many are wearing green hard hats
which were being given out at the University of
London Union, bearing the legend: "Tax the
banks not the students." Lots of calls from
speakers for police to avoid kettling, and anti-Liberal
Democrat rhetoric. Just been hearing from a
Camden School for Girls pupil, which was occupied
for 24 hours until this morning. Large police
presence here, although it's very peaceful so far.
An elderly man is playing the violin next to me.
12.18pm: Scotland Yard are once
again, to use that well-known phrase, predicting
a riot. These quotes are newly on PA from the
force's Superintendent Julia Pendry:
Protesters will be allowed sight and sound of
parliament. However, there is evidence to suggest
a number of people will come to London intent on
causing violence and disorder. They are jumping
on the bandwagon of these demonstrations with no
intention to protest or interest in student
tuition fees. This is of concern to us.
Those who come to London for peaceful protest
will be policed proportionately and appropriately.
But those who are intent on committing crime will
also be dealt with and they will suffer the
consequences of their actions.
uk
Student protests: today is our 1968 moment
A
coalition victory in the tuition fees vote could
turn our protest into a mass anti-privatisation
movement
Less than a month
after the first national student demonstration,
the coalition has given up on real argument. The
line now being pushed by Nick Clegg and David
Cameron is that students the full-time
readers, the doctoral researchers simply
haven't read the government's proposals, or don't
understand them.
We have read them,
and we don't like them. These proposals will put
up barriers to access for poorer students who
fear a lifetime of debt; they will hammer arts
and humanities; and they will lead to the closure
and merging of universities that are reliant on
teaching grants, most of which are
disproportionately populated with students from
less privileged backgrounds. Yes, the salary at
which graduates will start to repay tuition fees
has risen to £21,000; yes, there will be a
national bursary pot. But the concessions and apologies of recent days
pale in comparison to the privatisation and
marketisation of higher education. The reforms
threaten to turn universities into businesses and
students into compliant consumers. If the
protests have shown anything, it is that we are
nothing of the sort.
It is the government that is failing to
understand the situation. At the time of writing,
something like 30 universities have gone into
occupation, and school and FE students have come
out in tens of thousands to defend their right to
basic levels of educational maintenance support
and accessible university education. The
government is doing more than plugging a funding
gap, it is fundamentally changing the purpose of
education: not simply orientating it towards the
logic of the market, but introducing the market
directly into the system.
In response, we are witnessing the rebirth of
mass discontent in a serious form. Direct action,
a move away from the polite, self-indulgent
dissent of the last decade, has empowered a
generation of young people. Many of these newly
empowered students voted Lib Dem because they
believed that the Lib Dems offered electoral
reform, an end to two-party suffocation; and
because they promised all of them
to vote against a rise in tuition fees. The way
in which the coalition has behaved on fees has
fed into a broader disillusion. What was
presented as "new politics" looks empty
now, as reluctant Lib Dem MPs are pushed through
the lobbies by hook or by crook. If the
government wins today's vote on fees, it will not
be a moral victory and will certainly not
be the end of the student protest movement.
For now, students'
attention is fixed on the vote. People from all
over the country will march to parliament from the University of
London Union to demand that the Lib Dems
stick to their pledge, that electoral democracy
do its job, and that their voice be heard.
With just hours to
go until the vote, it is now undeniably possible
that the fee rise will pass. If it does, it will
be the task of everyone who wants to oppose the
wholesale marketisation of society to remain
steadfast. History tells us that repeal is a
serious possibility. The poll tax was passed and
defeated, as was the French CPE (first employment contract),
which threatened the basic rights of young people
at work.
The student movement is no longer picking at
the seams of a rise in fees; as in France in May
1968, the injustice of the vote may awaken a
broader crisis. But while in 1968 protesters
fought for a new society and a new history, today
we contest the supposed end of history the
idea that human progress is now and for ever
linked to free markets and corporate interests.
It is a paradigm that continues to form the
backbone of mainstream political discourse.
The government at the heart of this crisis has
nothing to offer us but palliatives: meagre
electoral reform, the odd quid for bursaries, the
hollow slogans of the "big society".
The popular unrest over education reforms is
threatening to bypass the rhetoric, and to spread
to millions of ordinary working people after
Christmas. Lib Dem MPs must now stick to their
pledge. If they don't, and the vote passes, they
will regret it.